Skip to Content

AOL Tech

libel posts

Web

Bully Web Site Lands Missouri Teen in Jail

Cyber-bullying has become a major issue around the world. Teens across the U.S. and across the pond in Europe find themselves constantly faced with this new form of harassment. But if we had to pick one place as the epicenter of this disturbing new trend it would be Missouri.

The home state of Megan Meier, a girl who committed suicide just before her 14th birthday as a result of being bullied on MySpace, was one of the first to pass anti-cyber-bullying legislation and to expand local harassment laws to cover digital communications. Since the passage of that law, several high-profile cases have come out of the state, including one that involved a 21-year-old woman sending threatening and vulgar text messages to a 17-year-old girl. Now, the state has another cyber-bullying incident garnering national attention. A ninth-grade girl from the town of Troy has been arrested for creating a Web site dedicated to harassing and mocking a fellow student.

Read more →

Celebrities, Web, Social Networking

Controversial Tweets Testing Limits of Free Speech


What separates Twitter from other social networking sites has always been its trademark brevity. Restricted to 140 characters, users are forced to be concise and truncate their thoughts, opinions, or news. As is often the case, though, pithiness comes at the expense of nuance, subtlety or sarcastic intonation, leaving tweets open to wide and varied interpretation. When the tweeter has some particularly strong opinions to get off his or her chest, feelings get hurt and, in some high-profile instances, lawsuits (and confusion) unfurl.

Courtney Love, for one, was recently sued by designer Dawn Simorangkir over a series of especially caustic tweets the singer posted. After having argued with Simorangkir over the price of vintage costumes, Love went on her own "Tweet Offensive," calling the fashionista a liar and a thief. Simorangkir sued Love for libel in March, according to the New York Times.

Read more →

Web, Social Networking

Alleged Bullies Sued Over Racist and Obscene Fake Facebook Profile

We're pretty sure that many victims of bullies would gladly go back to the good ol' days, when mocking and persecution didn't have the speed and reach the Internet affords. But bullies are quickly finding out that the Web doesn't provide as much protective anonymity as they may have thought.

One of the new avenues for bullying is impersonation via social networking sites. But four teens in Cook County, Illinois may have gone a little too far in alleged attacks on a high school athlete. They are now finding themselves defendants in a lawsuit that could have dire financial consequences for both them and their families. The four boys, identified only by their initials -- R.C., A.G., K.Z., and M.S. -- are being sued on five separate counts, including defamation and emotional distress, by the victim and his mother.

Read more →

Celebrities, Web

'Skanks' Blogger Sues Google for $15M for Divulging Identity

Last week, the notoriously anonymous 'Skanks in NYC' blogger was facing a potential defamation lawsuit by model Liksula Gentile Cohen, who had been negatively characterized in the blog. This week, that same blogger, who has since been identified as 27-year-old fashion student Rosemary Port, is filing a lawsuit of her own. According to ZDNet, she has decided to sue Google for revealing her identity to Cohen, and thus the world. She and attorney Salvatore Strazzullo are suing for $15 million.

"This has become a public spectacle and a circus that is not my doing," Port told the New York Daily News. Speaking of Cohen, Port continued, "By going to the press, she defamed herself... I feel my right to privacy has been violated."

Port's charges require some context. Last Monday, in the interest of pursuing a defamation suit, Cohen requested that a Manhattan Supreme Court judge subpoena Google for the identity of the 'Skanks in NYC' blogger. The judge did that very thing, and as was its legal obligation, Google obliged, identifying Port to the authorities and Cohen's lawyers. When she discovered the blogger to be none other than Port, whom she had known for some time, Cohen began to have doubts about the suit. Still, before Port had been publicly identified, Cohen told Diane Sawyer about the blogger, "[If] I've ever done anything to you to actually deserve this then I'm really very sorry." Some time over the past week, according to the Daily News, Cohen has apparently told her lawyer that she no longer wants to sue Port.

Read more →

Web, Social Networking

Critical Tweet Lands Chicago Tenant in Libel Suit

A sarcastic and critical tweet may end up costing a Chicago woman $50,000. On May 12th, Amanda Bonnen (whose Twitter page is currently down) allegedly complained about her then-landlord, the Horizon Group Management LLC, by typing, "Who said sleeping in a moldy apartment was bad for you? Horizon realty thinks it's okay."

According to the Sun Times, company representative Jeffrey Michael (whose family also happens to run the organization) said that there is no merit to the statements, so the group filed a libel suit against Bonnen on Monday. Seeking to maintain the company's positive reputation (even though the Better Business Bureau Web site indicates it's not an accredited company), Michael also warned, "We're a sue first, ask questions later kind of an organization."

Read more →

Celebrities, Web, Social Networking

St. Louis Cardinals Manager Tony La Russa Calls Foul on Twitter



St. Louis Cardinals' manager Tony La Russa has called, "You're out!" to Twitter. According to FOX News, the future hall-of-fame baseball manager filed suit last month against the microblogging site.

La Russa, who is seeking an unspecified amount in damages, claims a fake Twitter account set up in his name featured "derogatory and demeaning" comments that caused him emotional distress and injured his reputation. The most troubling tweets concern two former Cardinals pitchers -- unnamed in the article -- who have both died in the last few years. While the account is no longer active, pages from the lawsuit show a screenshot with a picture of La Russa and a heading that reads, "Hey there! Tony La Russa is using Twitter."

Read more →

Web

Olympian Skater's Mom Sues Google Over Blogger Post



No stranger to lawsuits, Google has faced any number of accusations, from misappropriating trade secrets to invading people's privacy with its Street View application. Well, according to MediaPost.com, the litigious mother of an Olympic athlete decided to file suit against Google last week because of allegedly defamatory comments posted through Google's Blogger service.

The comments, originally posted in 2006 by Sean Healy, accused Cherie Davis, the mother of Olympic speed skater Shani Davis, of lambasting members of the speed skating federation with charges of racism. On his blog 'Unknown Column,' Healy claimed that Ms. Davis, in her characterizations of federation members, used language like "'KKK'" and "'neo-Nazi genetic mutation'." Ms. Davis is now filing suit in the state of Illinois to have the blog removed.

The gold medalist's mother faces several legal obstacles with her lawsuit, as the Communications Decency Act protects Web sites from legal issues created by users' potentially libelous posts. According to MediaPost.com, for Healy's comments to be found libelous, Davis would have to not only prove that they were false, but also prove that Healy posted them with "reckless disregard" for whether they were in fact false or not. The latter part could be difficult to determine, considering Healy died in 2006. Hampering the case even further, an Illinois complainant must make her case within one year of the relevant material's being published, according to attorney Paul Alan Levy.

Read more →

Web

Dentist Sues Writer of Negative Online Yelp Review


Have you ever given someone or some business a bad review online? Well, you'd better keep what you write in check, or else you could end up getting sued like the California couple who bashed a dentist on Yelp.

Dr. Yvonne Wong, the dentist, is going forward with a lawsuit against Tai Jing and Jia Ma for libel and emotional distress after a court ruled that she had enough grounds for a case, or, as they put it, "a probability of success on the merits." In a user comment, the couple accused Wong of giving their four-year-old son a filling that contained mercury and of making him lightheaded from anesthetic gas. Wong's lawyers say that the parents' review makes it seem like she did so without their consent.

Jing and Ma tried to get the suit thrown out, citing a California law that bans anyone from preventing discussion of matters of public importance. We'd agree that mercury fillings should be examined, but we also understand why the judge didn't buy their argument. Wong, for her part, also tried to sue Yelp, but that went nowhere, as the federal Communications Decency Act protects sites from any lawsuits due to user comments.

Read more →

Blogger Sued for Negative Book Reviews

Blogger Sued for Negative Book ReviewsLibel suits are notoriously tough to argue, and even more so when the target of the suit is a critic. The dictionary defines 'libel' as:

A written or oral statement about another which is malicious and false and will do harm to that person or his/her reputation, by tending to bring the target into ridicule, hatred, scorn or contempt of others.

Professional reviewers don't normally get targeted for libel, since tearing apart other people and their work tends to be part of the job requirement. But, that's not stopping author Stuart Pivar, who is suing the Seed Media Group and Paul Z. Myers for a pair of negative blog posts about Mr. Pivar's books 'Lifecode: The Theory of Biological Self Organization' and 'Lifecode: From Egg to Embryo by Self-Organization.'

Myers's review of 'Lifecode: The Theory of Biological Self Organization' was a whole-heartedly negative affair. The only positive things Myers -- a PHD holding University of Minnesota professor -- had to say about the book was that the binding was of high quality and the scientifically inaccurate illustrations were very pretty. When Pivar's 'Lifecode: From Egg to Embryo by Self-Organization' landed on Myers's desk, things turned downright vicious. Myers had the following to say:

"The doodles in this book bear absolutely no relationship to anything that goes on in real organisms, but after staring at them for a while, I realized what this book is actually about. This book is a description of the development and evolution of balloon animals. It's that bad. This is a book suitable only for use at clown colleges, and even there, I suspect the clowns would tell us that it is impractical, nonsensical, and has no utility in their craft."

Ouch!

The question is, whether this actually constitutes libel. As a reviewer and a qualified critic of the science behind the book, did Myers intentionally and maliciously set out to make Pivar look like a fool? Can Pivar come up with the evidence to show that Myers's assertions about the science behind 'LifeCode' are false? There are many dimensions to the case, not the least of which is a question of journalistic integrity and freedom of speech. Imagine if Microsoft could sue us for our lukewarm review of Windows Live Hot Mail. Trust us, we'll be keeping an eye on this one.

From Boing Boing

Related Links:

Switched Video

Follow Switched on Twitter

Deals of the Day

Latest Reviews from CNET.com

CNET provides the latest tech news, unbiased reviews, videos, podcasts, software, and downloads, making tech products easy to find, understand and use.

Top Product Reviews

  • Home Audio Reviews

    9.0 out of 10

    Definitive Technology BPX
    Works great with Dolby Pro Logic and Dolby Digital. Full Review

    9.0 out of 10

    Denon AVR-4306 (black)
    Incredibly well-featured 7.1-channel receiver; excellent sound quality; three HDMI inputs; converts analog video to HDMI output; upconverts analog video to 720p/1080i HD resolution; iPod and USB MP3 player connectivity; Internet radio and MP3/WMA streaming audio via built-in Ethernet port; XM Satellite Radio compatible; touch-screen remote; multizone, multisource operation; browser-based control via home network; accurate autocalibration routine. Full Review

    8.8 out of 10

    KEF KHT3005 (black)
    The KEF KHT-3005 is one compact, beautifully designed speaker package with solid aluminum satellites that feature unique driver technology to produce incredible clarity. Meanwhile, the equally astounding dual 10-inch, 250-watt powered subwoofer delivers ultradeep bass. Full Review

  • Cell Phone Reviews

    8.7 out of 10

    SignalBoost Mobile Professional Amplifier Kit
    The Mobile Professional Amplifier delivers a powerful signal boost to your cell phone. Also, it offers a compact design and easy setup. Full Review

    8.6 out of 10

    Wi-Ex zBoost YX510-PCS-CEL cell phone signal extender
    The Wi-Ex zBoost YX510-PCS-CEL significantly boosts your cell phone reception and is easy to operate. Also, it uses a wireless connection to your phone. Full Review

    8.3 out of 10

    LG VX6000 (Verizon Wireless)
    Compact and stylish; impressive battery life; solid audio quality; sharp color screen; built-in camera; USB ready; affordable. Full Review

  • Digital Camera Reviews

    9.3 out of 10

    Canon EOS 1D Mark III
    Extremely fast, 10-megapixel continuous shooting; very low noise; highly customizable; well-designed body with weather sealing; 3-inch LCD; abundant optional accessories. Full Review

    9.3 out of 10

    Nikon D3 (body only)
    Full-frame sensor; well designed, pro-level weather-sealed body; very low noise, even at extremely high ISOs; fast. Full Review

    9.0 out of 10

    Canon EOS-1Ds Mark III
    Very low noise, high quality images; 21.1 megapixels; live view shooting; pro-level build-quality and performance. Full Review

  • Desktop Reviews

    8.9 out of 10

    Velocity Micro Edge Z30 (Intel Core i7)
    Best value among midrange gaming PCs; Velocity Micro's consistently high build quality; compact case makes few sacrifices; second graphics card slot previously uncommon at this price. Full Review

    8.5 out of 10

    Apple iMac (24-inch, 2.8GHz)
    A minor specification update results in some significant performance gains; graphics upgrade an option on this 24-inch model; sleek, polished design didn't receive an update, but we won't start clamoring for a new design until the current one is at least 12 months old. Full Review

    8.4 out of 10

    Velocity Raptor Signature Edition Gaming PC
    One of the fastest PCs we've tested; a PCI Express RAID card helps media encoding performance; typically immaculate Velocity Micro assembly; strong, three-year warranty. Full Review

Featured Galleries

Nissan Land Glider
Vintage Keyboards
Retro Computer Logos
Vintage Computer Festival
Motorola CLIQ
iPod touch
iTunes 9
Video iPod Nano
The Beatles: Rock Band

 

Switched Desktop

Get the New Switched Desktop

Latest tech news, Switched mail, and more.

AOL Tech Network

Resources

Autoblog

Daily Finance

Download Squad

Engadget

Joystiq

Urlesque

Fanhouse Main

WalletPop

Gadling