Leopard Vs. Vista: Cage Match
There's nothing like a good Vista / OS X showdown to get the fan-boys all riled up. Our pals at Engadget have pieced together a pretty comprehensive table comparing the features, strengths, and weaknesses of these two operating systems behemoths for PCs and Macs, respectively. (The latest Mac update to OS X, Leopard, launched late last week). We have our own opinions, which we'll detail here.
Like your average frat boy, most users only care about how easy and pretty a computer is. While Engadget hasn't declared a victor in the field of aesthetics, we're not so humble. As you may have noticed from previous postings, we're no Apple cultists, but Leopard certainly has the one-up on VIsta in the design department. Compared to the sleek, clean and consistent (if a little flashy) look of OS X, 10.5 Vista is like a mangy alley cat is costume jewelry. The tacky implementation of transparency, patches of XP throwbacks, wanna-be desktop widgets (called "gadgets),and pseudo-modern design make Vista a train wreck in the user interface (UI) department... but that's just our subjective opinion.
Otherwise Vista shines in many respects, compared to OS X. The upgraded version and powerful version of Windows Explorer exposes Mac's Finder for what it is, a bare-bones file manager with some gaudy tricks of debatable usefulness thrown in. And while Front Row -- the Mac's Tivo-esque media interface -- is sleek and simple, it's simply no match for the full blown Media Center packed into every Vista box. Redmond also has a leg up when it comes to wireless networking, giving you far more information in a glance than OS X, which doesn't even tell you the strength of Wi-Fi signals it picks up. As for entertainment, unless your idea of gaming is getting together with the girls to play Bridge every week, there is simply no option other than Vista. Sure, Macs work with iTunes, if that's your cup of tea, but you can still get more music (for just $12 a month for subscription services), movies and TV shows (at places like Amazon Unbox and Netflix), and games (all Mac gaming titles are afterthoughts or conversions from PCs).
This is not to say that Leopard is all looks and no brains. OS X's virtual desktops, called Spaces, keep you from being overwhelmed by Windows, while Expose proves to be a much more efficient way of switching between applications than the standard Windows tasks switcher, or the completely useless Flip 3D. It also goes with out saying that OS X is more secure than Windows. The smaller market share and Unix underpinnings make it more secure both by default and by design. Leopard's true strong suit though is making tasks, that under Windows can be difficult if not impossible, so simple that Jerry Seinfeld could never write a grating, over-rated bit about how confusing it is. Time Machine makes backing up and restoring not only amazingly simple, but fun, while Boot Camp allows those with out computer science degrees to dual boot OS X and Vista in case you're indecisive.
The coup de grace though is a 1-2 punch, iLife and price. iLife gives every Mac user hobbyist level photo, music, and video editing applications. Microsoft puts it's own nail in its coffin though. Leopard is $129. One edition. One price. No matter what. Vista? Well there's the Ultimate Edition, Home Premium, Home Basic, and Business, amongst more niche versions. All have different prices for a full install and an upgrade. An upgrade from XP to Home Basic will run only $99, but then you miss out on many of the features that are supposed to make Vista so special, including the eye candy. If you want to buy Ultimate outright... well you might want to remortgage your house. 4 versions, 8 prices, the whole ordeal is so dizzying we're shocked people aren't jumping off the roofs of Best Buys across the nation.
In the end Engadget has Apple edging out Windows taking 46 head to head match ups while Vista garners 41 victories. We pretty much agree. OS X is clearly a more solid operating system, but it's not without its blemishes. Your final decision should be base on your needs and personal preference. Oh, and there's always Linux... but that's a story for another day.
From Engadget
Related links:









