
We're quickly coming up on a year since the iPad was released, and while opinions may have been divided early on, there's simply no questioning now that Apple's take on the tablet PC singlehandedly made that long-failing device category suddenly viable. Apple didn't invent the tablet; it was simply the first to craft one that was compelling enough to finally win over consumers. Along the way, it has sold in the millions and become the undisputed champ, utterly crushing the few uninspired and hamfisted pretenders to the throne.
As you may have heard, this year's CES has been blandly dubbed "The Year of the Tablet" in recognition of the piles of tablets that will be crowding store shelves this year from virtually every big name company you've heard of, and many you haven't. Yet, the early word from pundits has almost resoundingly been one of mocking resignation, with the assumption that the iPad, and its presumed successor this spring, are an unstoppable juggernaut. There is some logic and appeal to that argument -- it's easy to vote for the frontrunner -- but, as Grandpa used to say, we think that's a bunch of absolute horsepucky.
For one, we'd point out that Samsung's Galaxy Tab has already sold over a million units worldwide in just a few months -- despite predictions to the contrary from naysayers all over. But our strongest argument is that fact that we've seen a handful of tablets that at least equal the iPad's appeal, and even one or two that surpass it. Granted, a lot of the iPad's appeal comes from its seamless interaction with a solid and popular app and media ecosystem, and so any aspiring contenders have a lot of catching up to do to convince buyers they won't be left out in the cold. In the case of Android Tablets, that shouldn't be hard with the Android Market, but it will likely be the defining factor in the rest's success or failure.
Below are our top tablet picks for 2011, and the ones we think have a fair chance of gobbling iPad market share in the coming year. Let the betting begin.
1. Motorola Mobility Xoom
As we discovered with the Atrix, the engineering elves at Motorola have been burning the midnight oil. Their Xoom is by far the most full-featured tablet we've seen, packing a dual-core processor, front- and rear-facing cameras, 720p video recording and 1080p playback (including Flash 10.1) on its crisp 10.1-inch screen. It comes with a 802.11N Wi-FI and a 3G antenna (for Verizon) but, get this, is upgradable to LTE/4G in the future with a simple hardware swap -- an ingenious first. It comes standard with 32GB of storage but also has a microSD slot, as well as micro USB that will support flash drives. It also will come standard with the coveted Android 3.0, or Honeycomb. We can't say enough how solid, stable and gorgeous this machine is, which will hit shelves in the next couple months.
Motorola Xoom
2. BlackBerry PlayBook
While RIM has been taking it to the chin for its lack of offerings in the phone market of late, it seems clear now that's because the PlayBook has taken precedence. It's another muscle-bound, dual-core destroyer, but unlike the Xoom (or iPad) it has a smaller 7-inch but still-HD display. In our fiddlings, it handled multitasking unbelievably well, allowing for two HD videos to continue streaming simultaneously. Like the Xoom it also has HD cameras on both sides, micro USB and HDMI outputs, a full suite of wireless tech (802.11N Wi-fi, Bluetooth 2.1 +EDR) including 4G, and functionally will work a lot like a BlackBerry, pretty much assuring it'll be the pick of choice for business-types. Now, if you please, RIM, bring this polish to your smartphones.
BlackBerry PlayBook
3. Samsung Galaxy Tab LTE
As we mentioned, the Tab has already sold phenomenally well abroad and the addition of a new 802.11N Wi-Fi model at a lower price will only speed up sales. And for good reason -- this 7-incher is fun, powerful and satisfying to use (Click
here for our full review of the current model). Samsung's announcement that an LTE-equipped model will be coming out later this year only sweetens the deal for us.
Galaxy Tab LTE
4. Vizio VIA Tablet
Cali-based upstart Vizio has grown up to become one of the country's foremost purveyors of lower-cost but generally innovative and well-built HDTVs in recent years, and as of this CES it's thrown down the gauntlet. In addition to a phone, Vizio plans to release the 8-inch Android VIA tablet this summer. While the announced specs are nice enough, what gets us jazzed is Vizio's reputation for putting together a quality product, along with the tablet's planned integration into Vizio's
VIA Plus ecosystem -- which is Google TV coupled with Vizio's custom Internet apps (VIA, get it?). It should work somewhat like
DLNA , allowing Vizio products to seamlessly network and share content. You know, sort of like what Apple has done. It's a risky proposition, but the VIA tablet is a good start.
Vizio VIA Tablet
Tags: blackberry, Blackberry playbook, BlackberryPlaybook, ces 2011, Ces2011, motorola, motorola mobility xoom, MotorolaMobilityXoom, playbook, Samsung galaxy tab, SamsungGalaxyTab, slate, tablet, top, via, vizio, vizio via tablet, VizioViaTablet, xoom
Comments
7
Subscribe to commentsNemephosisJan 9th 2011 11:34AM
If RIM brought the Playbook's power and abilities to their Blackberry phones, they wouldn't be having the problem they are now (you know, the problem of everybody not wanting their crappy phones in favour of ones that actually do stuff.)
bobwohlrabJan 12th 2011 11:26PM
Engadget seems to be only interested in tablet PHONES. There are thousands of us out there that don't want to hold a 7" tablet to our ear or on bluetooth to make phone calls. I have a cell phone. I like a 7" tablet as I travel for ebook reading, email and internet. The size is perfect and after looking and researching I chose one running Android 2.2. The main thing I can't understand is why Google locks up Android Market so we can't reach it. If a specific app won't run on my 7" tablet oh well!! Haven't you ever had a Windows app not work on your PC. Why make a operating system and then only let PHONE people get to the apps. Sometimes Tech Companies gets tunnel vision and just wants to cram anything and everything into one device. Will Google soon release 3.1 and we will have a device that will wake us up, jump in our pocket or purse and run our entire day so man will no longer have to think!!!!!!!!!!!
Two Dogs A HumpinJan 10th 2011 4:13PM
Oh Poo Poo, I am Not This Geekie, Am I ?
sporty1jroJan 10th 2011 5:21PM
So tired of Apple marketing and the Apple kool-aid drinkers who keep saying the same thing "no one thought it was useful or that anyone needed what it did, and it has tons of shortcomings" "but surprisingly millions have been sold" and also "its the best because Steve Jobs told us it is". Usually about 5 million items of Apple products are always sold at their introduction and updated hardware (replacements for last year's model) because there is a rabid core of 5,000,000 Appholes who always buy anything and everything Apple releases, no matter how useless or absurd, including the iPad. These people are the ones who buy the yearly updates to Apple hardware, and have a room full of the old Apple hardware from prior years.
CinthyaJan 10th 2011 7:55PM
I received the Coby Kyros tablet for Christmas. I definitely recommend it to anyone who's looking for an inexpensive, yet highly functional tablet. Android OS with WiFi, touch screen and a great selection of apps for free ebooks. Retails for about $200. It's beautiful, yet simple. Highly recommend.
product_alertJan 18th 2011 1:49PM
I found this interesting comparison between Galaxy Tab and iPad that is based on analysis of hundreds of their customer reviews. Your and your readers may be interested to see this analysis as well http://blog.amplifiedanalytics.com/2010/11/851/.
You can also check reputation of other products if you go to http://www.amplifiedanalytics.com/V2P-Product-Reviews/Demo, enter the product name or number (like "Samsung LN55C650 55-Inch 1080p 120 Hz LCD HDTV") and click on "Submit" button. The system will aggregate and analyze customer reviews to calculate the reputation metrics for you and will let you read the reviews if you want to.
PeteJan 26th 2011 11:07AM
As an iPad owner I'm impressed and pleased to see a few contenders in the tablet market that actually have good products. The Motorola looks especially interesting and feature loaded. I'm also somewhat impressed with the Samsung Galaxy and recognize the smaller size is more appealing for reading books.
What I didn't see mentioned anywhere here (sorry if I missed it) is battery life. If I got 10 hours on my iPad it would be a bad day. Its simply the best for it's power longevity and a mobile device should be for those of us not tethered to offices and homes all day. I'm pretty skeptical the Motorola would have even half the battery life with all those features and flash. The Galaxy may be somewhat better with a smaller screen but with no data its only a guess. I "sacrificed" flash for battery life in the iPad and have no regrets. What do these devices offer for real field tested battery life?