Best Bookshelf Speakers With Big Sound for Few Bucks

Dear Reader: It's always heartening to hear when some young go-getter -- presumably raised on low-quality MP3s and even lower-quality earbuds -- stands up for audio fidelity. We salute you, sir! (Of course, you're also expecting top quality on the cheap, but we'll forgive your sense of entitlement and chalk it up to youthful exuberance.)
Anyway, we've done the stroll down desktop speaker row ourselves, and have found that the selection generally isn't to our liking. While certainly there are plenty of great 5.1 and 7.1 surround systems, and even 2.1 systems that provide pretty good boom for the buck, when you get into the self-powered computer speaker realm, the pickings get slimmer; cheap plastic bodies and alternately tinny or flat sounds saturate the market. But, as you might guess, we do have a winner for you, and, in case you have a severely limited budget, we've included a cheaper runner-up (as well as a top-shelf pick, should your roommates step up and chip in).
Best Under $100
Our pick for best overall buy is a set of swingin' M-Audio Stereophile AV30 speakers, priced nicely at a penny less than 100 bucks. The first thing you'll notice when picking up a pair is that these puppies are husky -- just under 10 pounds to be exact. This is a good thing, and, since the speaker housings are made of sturdy medium density fiberboard (MDF) for vibration elimination, they allow for better audio output than their plastic equivalents. Put to the test against our iTunes playlist, the AV30s pump out appreciably fuller, cleaner sound with more bass kick than any comparable speaker we've tested. Listening to a genre-traveling mix that took us from Kanye, Mos Def and The Roots, to Radiohead, classic Bowie, Air, Desmond Dekker and a little Shostakovich (among others), we were literally and figuratively blown away by the ample distortion-free volume -- even when using the 'bass-boost' switch. While we're sure you'd notice the difference between the AV30s and a system with a dedicated subwoofer, there's still plenty of clean bass "thump." Think of it as enough to boogie down without getting a noise violation. Besides the RCA input on the back (as the speakers nicely come with an RCA-to-1/8-inch cable), the AV30s also have an auxiliary input up front, in case your roommates tire of your musical stylings, and want to plug in their own iPod or laptop without fiddling with your connections.
Best Under $50
Should you not be able to muster 100 clams, our low-budget pick is the Logitech Z320 speaker system, widely available for $50 or less. Slick and stylish and solidly made (for a plastic speaker housing, anyway), the Z320s don't have anywhere near the bass thump as the AV30s, and feature much lower power, but still perform well. They also have a unique, rear-facing driver in each unit, so that sound is omnidirectional, which, depending on how you set them up (i.e., not inches from the wall), can make for a fuller overall sound. The only real downside, besides a lack of bass oomph, is that at full volume you may get distortion. So, keep it light, okay?Best Under $200
Should you find that you have a little extra scratch to play with, well then, you'll want to skip the above, and invest in a $200 pair of Audioengine 2 (A2) speakers. Think of them as a souped-up version of the AV30s. They have a wider frequency response, more powerful bass, more volume power and pricier components (such as a kevlar woofer) -- all despite having a smaller footprint. They're also slicker-looking to our eyes -- if that sort of thing matters to you -- and are worth the price if your student's budget can allow it. So splurge, and think of them, like ECON 101, as an investment in your future.





Live from Microsoft's New Generation Xbox event!
Xbox Reveal liveblog on Joystiq
Dozens Killed in Oklahoma Tornado; Death Toll to Rise
Justin Bieber Booed, Gets Standing Ovation at Billboard Music Awards
2013 Billboard Music Awards Best and Worst Dressed
Watch: Kansas Meteorologist Seeks Shelter From Tornado
Xbox One architecture panel liveblog!
Selena Gomez Leaving Justin Bieber's House: Booty Call Rumors Swirl
Two Pilots Fired After Brazilian Pop Star Takes Captain's Seat Mid-Flight















Comments
8
Subscribe to commentsUberSilSep 20th 2010 8:23PM
Any speaker manufacturer who doesn't list the specifications on their speakers shouldn't be purchased from. Thus I think the M-Audio brand is worthless as a set of drivers. However if you're willing to put some elbow grease into the situation and you live in North America you can get everything you need to do the job yourself. High quality pickups, cross-overs (apparently they aren't as expensive as I thought), high-end drivers (I recommend a piezo horn tweeter and a full range) and even box requirements. Only thing they don't sell is wood and screws. www.loudspeaker.ca
Pks29733Sep 24th 2010 8:41AM
Instead of wasting money on 'high end' speakers (if you have a crappy radio/receiver these won't help) buy a 'surround sound' tv speakers (you know the 'left-right' speakers, a 'bass unit' and a pair of rear speakers.) set. Shop around and you will find deals. I bought a new set at a national 'electronics' chain for a gift for $35 bucks. What student has $200 bucks to blow on speakers?
mreinh8936Oct 17th 2010 9:46AM
The Audio Engines are a great set of speaks. I've got the 5's and they are little masterpieces. College students not able to afford them? Disagree. College students live by music and these fit good audio nicely in a small package. They also make great CHRISTMAS GIFTS! Ioved giving them out. My speaks are jacked into my pooter, and sometimes make it out to my dock (BTW, my main system is all tubes...Macintosh, Sunfire, Audio physic...etc ....high end....and my ears like these little fellows).
Enjoy!
mreinh8936Oct 17th 2010 9:48AM
PS. No amp required....theys guys have a built in amp....self powered. So just hook in your mp3 player and go. I use the remote on my Zune. Nice since I can adjust volume and skip tracks
paulOct 17th 2010 10:18AM
i got a pair of altec lansing with a small sub at wall mart for under 50 ,and they jam really well
S ValiantOct 17th 2010 1:51PM
I highly recommend purchasing a pair of Energy e:xl:15's or (if you can find them) e:xl:16's on eBay. Although they are nearly ten years old, they were originally about $300/$350 pair and performed as well as some speakers costing 2.5 to three times the price. They should set you back no more than $100 including shipping.
HR-MusicmanOct 17th 2010 2:31PM
Forget M-audio, they were kinda hip 2 years ago. The writer should be more up on current product. Samson Studio Dock 4.1 out performs, has an Ipod dock, and costs less. I bought mine here: http://www.bananasmusic.com/productdetail.asp/pid_8853/productname_Samson-StudioDock-4i-USB-Studio-Monitors-with-Integrated-iPod-Dock
They even offer a smaller version for under $100
JonathanOct 17th 2010 9:49PM
For a little bit more ($316/pair shipped to your door), you can have great sounding bookshelf speakers from Axion (axiomaudio.com). I bought the M2's for my daughter who is in college. Whenever someone new hears them, they comment on how good sounding they are. Excellent construction, heavy (11+lbs) but portable. Perfect for the dorm room and for the home.