What Underwater Point-and-Shoot Camera Should I Get?

Dear Reader: We totally agree. In our perfect world, every camera would be waterproof, shockproof, scratch-proof, lightweight and be able to snap perfect photos without a fuss. Encouragingly, several camera companies are taking steps in the right direction with moderately priced waterproof/ruggedized models already available from Canon, Fujifilm, Olympus, Pentax and Sony, among others. Less encouraging is that virtually all of them have some hiccup that leaves us wanting.
Though you say you're looking strictly for a point-and-shoot model, we want to temper your expectations a bit and say that if you ever plan on venturing into scuba depths (30 feet and deeper), or are really looking for National Geographic-quality photos of marine flora and fauna, then you'd be better off opting for a DSLR camera, a waterproof housing and, probably, a dedicated flash. Period. Waterproof cameras are fun to use and can produce some great results, but it turns out shooting underwater can be maddeningly tricky, and you shouldn't expect to rival Cousteau (or Zissou) with a $300 camera.
That said, we recently tested a few waterproof point-and-shoot models, and came back pretty psyched on Canon's PowerShot D10 (from about $285 online). It's one of only a few models that can go 30-plus-feet deep. That may sound like overkill, but we're fans of buying with flexibility in mind. The D10's other specs are pretty standard for the category: 12.1 megapixels, 35mm equivalent lens, a 3x optical zoom, 2.5-inch LCD viewer, and a plethora of scene modes. One minor feature we especially like is the D10's unique precision-locking mounts on the four corners of its body, allowing you to instantly reconnect the strap or add another one. They're so pleasingly precise and well engineered, we'd love to see them appear on everything from laptops to messenger bags.
In our tests, the D10 took 'pretty good' to 'very good' photos underwater (from about 10 to 15 feet deep), and some 'very good' to 'excellent' ones above. In fact, leaving the camera in Underwater mode while snapping on land produced highly saturated shots that can be gorgeous. (We've included a few in the above gallery.) The D10 also adjusts between macro and regular modes on the fly, so close-up shots have a nice, shallow depth of field that many point-and-shoots can't attain.
Our major complaint was that we had a heck of a time framing shots, due to glare on the LCD and the difficulty of holding steady while swimming and trying to shoot a moving object. A wide-angle lens would be a wonderful improvement, as would be one-handed zooming. When we did manage to get something in frame, our photos generally looked pretty good, though focus was sometimes soft. Having taken several dozen shots, we came back with plenty of keepers. Shooting video (at standard definition 640 x 480) was a real blast, especially with the swirling sound of moving water. Taking all of the above into consideration, and assuming you aren't heading 20,000 leagues under the sea, the D10 is a solid choice and a real catch for the money.
More from Just Tell Me What to Get:






Forbidden America: Cold War-Era Map Shows No-Go Zones For Soviet Tourists
Tenants: Stench of Death Makes St. Louis Complex 'Unlivable'
Chili's Waitress Fired Over Facebook Post Insulting 'Stupid Cops'
2013 Billboard Music Awards: All the Winners!
2013 Billboard Music Awards: Arrivals Photos From the Blue Carpet!
Ricardo Cerezo, Facing Eviction, Finds $4.85 Million Lottery Ticket
Man Takes Dump In Background Of Instructional Workout Video
MIT's cheetah robot runs faster, more efficiently, can carry its own power supply (video)
Forever 21 Worker Fired After She Tells Her Traumatic Story
Style Throwback: Cannes Film Festival













Comments
7
Subscribe to commentsHawaii TomMar 8th 2010 1:49PM
I can't believe that your list is missing the most innovative manufacturer: Panasonic. After years of researching the existing UW P&S contenders, I kept waiting for perfection, and found it with the Lumix DMC-TS1. Besides the 12 MP, shockproof to 6 feet, waterproof to 10 feet, it has 2 things the others don't. First, a true 28 MM wide, with OIS and 4x zoom. But most importantly, it shoots 720p HD underwater! Nothing else does! After years of shooting UW stills, I realized that they all sucked because fish move! Capturing the motion of a school of tangs with HD video in a palm sized camera has been a joy for the last year. Now, they have followed up with the TS2, which can go down to 10 meters. Don't leave Panasonic off your radar ever again!
ChefRussApr 7th 2010 8:29PM
Don't buy the Panasonic. Leaks! In 6 months the price has gone from almost $400 to the low $200's. Panasonic knows they have an issue. Ceck out the weak reviews on Amazon and others. All leakers. Loed the camera for 6 months. Hate Pnasonic when they say tough luck. Not covered by warranty. Good luck.
Jon ChaseMar 8th 2010 2:01PM
Hawaii Tom,
We heartily agree that the TS1 is feature-packed, but it didn't make our short list since it was limited to depths of 10 feet or less--we really wanted a unit that allowed for maximum flexibility and wasn't limited to pools and shallow snorkeling use. But we eagerly await the release of the TS2 (along with the Pentax Optio W90 as well) and our next vacation!
Hawaii TomMar 8th 2010 3:06PM
Understood, Jon, but the "scuba-depth" comment in your lede was very accurate. I let my certification lapse because in the last 30 years I have found that snorkeling and some free-diving got me to 98% of the really good pictures I wanted. 10 feet down is really a surprisingly long way when you try it, and your ears hurt if you're not used to it. I'd say the other strengths of the TS1 far outweigh the depth limitation, and as the TS2 is released, it will be a great time for bargains on the TS1. I wouldn't want people to avoid what I believe is one of the best OVERALL contenders beause of a limitation that most will never come close to bumping up against.
Ed KelleyMar 8th 2010 5:08PM
I totally agree with your praise of the Canon D10. I just ordered my second!! Yep, lost the first one overboard on a snorkel trip....Someone will probably find it with some of the best pictures I have ever taken...
George R. HornMar 8th 2010 7:55PM
No matter what point and shoot you use you still can not compare to a SLR housed camera or even a Nikonos V. I am a photographer, have shot underwater for years. The first thing you loose as you go under is the hot colors, red, yellow, orange, within 15 ft they are almost gone unless the water is very clear and their is bright sun. Any camera can leak, my suggestion is get a housed camera if you plan on shooting underwater a lot.
IskandarMar 8th 2010 11:38PM
I agree that Canon D10 is can dive quite deep.
But that shouldn't be a deciding criteria. If deep waterproof rating is what your reader needs, he should get a Hero camera. It's waterproof to 100 feet and can take photos automatically every few seconds.
You should also mention that the D10 can take sharp pictures, but not videos. If your reader needs to record videos while being rocked in a kayak or boat, he'll be extremely disappointed with D10.
Yes, Panasonic TS1 can't dive as deep. But the pictures are just as good as the Canon and the HD video are much better than the Canon. You can see what I'm talking about here :-
http://www.waterproof-camera.org/videos-shot-using-panasonic-ts1-camera/