What's the Best Affordable Blu-ray Player With Streaming Video?

Dearest Reader: If you ask us, Blu-ray technology is in a transition period, so bear with our rant while we try to answer your timely and excellent question.
The Blu-ray situation is a little confounding for us at the moment. Lest we be wrongly accused by videophiles in the comments section, we love movies on Blu-ray and freely agree that its audio and video quality are unparalleled. The problem we have is with the current crop of Blu-ray players. Unbelievably, the market is still plagued by an abundance of unstandardized spec lists (e.g., lack of HDMI 1.3 or BD-Live support), widespread tech foibles (e.g., unreliable networking, system freezes, audio sync), and relatively high prices to boot. Unlike a bare-bones $75 upscaling DVD player that just works, Blu-ray players often just don't (based on the thousands of anecdotal customer reviews from dozens of online sites we've perused).
This is all just to say: we think you should either spend a little bit of money on a low-end and low-risk machine for now, or pony up for a Sony PlayStation 3. The basic Blu-rays we've seen that hover around the $150 mark are almost all under-featured. However, the one exception (and we can't believe we're saying this) is Best Buy's $150 house brand Insignia NS-BRDVD3. It's ugly, doesn't play all the advanced audio formats beyond TrueHD, and doesn't have built-in Wi-Fi. (Although, the next model up, which we'd also recommend, does offer it for $30 more.) That said, it's speedy, does a nice job of up-converting old DVDs for better picture quality, has built-in Netflix streaming, supports BD-Live, and is a reliable player overall. Lastly, in stark contrast to many other brands, Insignia offers a one-year warranty (unlike, say, Samsung's 90 days) should the unit crap out.
When you start getting into the $250 range, you'll generally get better picture quality, loads more audio options and inputs, and Wi-Fi (which beats stringing Ethernet cable around your house). But then you're within range of the PS3's price, and the PS3 is the fastest, most reliable, and best-performing Blu-ray player at its price point. (And it obviously lets you play PS3 games, if that's your dad's kind of thing.) We're prepared to say that if you're going to spend $250 or so, you may as well go for the $300 PS3, and know that you're getting a solid machine with an option to play games. Our one caveat, though, is that the PS3 currently requires the use of a specialized DVD (which Netflix will send you for free) whenever you use Netflix streaming; that will be resolved with a firmware update in the new year, however, so it isn't really a deal-breaker for us.
One final option we'll mention in passing is the fantastic Roku HD, a $99 box that basically acts like an intermediary between the Internet and your A/V system, letting you stream HD and SD movies and music from all of the largest online media sources (except iTunes). It's simple to use, easy to set up, and just works, as the kids say. Sure, it can't play Blu-ray, but -- in all honesty -- we suspect we'll have forgotten about that whole thing in a few years, anyway.
More from Just Tell Me What to Get:






Live from Microsoft's New Generation Xbox event!
Xbox Reveal liveblog on Joystiq
Dozens Killed in Oklahoma Tornado; Death Toll to Rise
Justin Bieber Booed, Gets Standing Ovation at Billboard Music Awards
2013 Billboard Music Awards Best and Worst Dressed
Watch: Kansas Meteorologist Seeks Shelter From Tornado
Xbox One architecture panel liveblog!
Two Pilots Fired After Brazilian Pop Star Takes Captain's Seat Mid-Flight
Oldest Water on Earth Found Deep Underground
Selena Gomez Leaving Justin Bieber's House: Booty Call Rumors Swirl














Comments
25
Subscribe to commentsCarneyDec 7th 2009 1:05PM
The PS3 is also a modern update to the old family slide projector and home movie projector - it does a good job at importing snapshots and home videos from your digital camera and intuitively organizing and displaying them, all on your TV without having to haul out a roll-up screen.
On top of that, it not only plays music CDs, but also imports and stores their songs, like a computer. Pop the CD in once, let the PS3 copy its contents and spit it out, and you have it available forever.
Still another feature is being able to rent or buy TV shows and movies separately or in addition to Netflix.
Yet another is free audio chat and even video phone calls (with an optional camera attachment) with other PS3 users, so you can do Star Trek style big screen video phone calls with family far away, as long as they also have a PS3 and the PS Eye.
Still another is being able to surf the web, using a standard keyboard and mouse, or a special wireless one sold by Logitech. You can even attach a printer to print out web pages.
All that's without even mentioning games.
The PS3 really is the perfect centerpiece to a home theater system.
SandyDec 13th 2009 5:03PM
great info, thanks!
joehennesMar 23rd 2010 4:51PM
PS3 sux. Mine lasted just past the end of the warranty period then died completely without warning. This prompted me to go online and find out many people have this problem. Even people who like their PS3s admit you have to buy a new one every couple years. That is not quality to me.
I bought a low end straight Blu-Ray player instead.
Half as much, better picture, better sound. Period.
Paul GrunseichDec 13th 2009 2:45PM
Anything made by Best Buy like their Insignia brand usually stinks. I allowed myself to get suckered into buying an Insignia TV 32" for a "great" price that was, "as good as a Sony". It was for my daughter's dorm room so I figured what the heck and bought it. What a mistake. In less than 3 months the sound went, I had to retrieve it and exchange it and it was a real pain in the neck. I licked my wounds and paid the $150 difference and got the real Sony that I should have bought in the first place and was sadly the wiser for my stupidity. Plus, you always need to be wary of Best Buy's "power pricing" scam that usually not even their sales people know about. That's how they sucker you into the place with their special version of the old bait and switch. They send you these great coupons to get you into the store and once there are told that the coupons don't apply to their items that are "power priced" meaning anything that's actually good so you have to buy their junk to get the discount. They claim their power pricing is the rock bottom lowest an item can be and therefore the coupons don't apply. What a crock. I never shop there for anything significant unless it's a DVD or some other small item. I wrote to complain about this and got one phone call but they never followed up and have since lost me as a regular customer. Word to the wise...avoid Best Buy at all costs and especially any of their in store brands like Insignia
IndESkater15Dec 16th 2009 8:07PM
did you not read the coupons before you went to the store? they specifically state not valid on certain items so maybe reading what the coupon says instead of seeing 10% off and running to the store like a retard would help. and being a best buy employee i have never heard of anything called "power pricing" and our sales all last for one week and change every sunday. customers like you make me hate going to work. dont cry because everything doesnt work the way you want it to, corporations have to make money too and half the stuff in the home theater department goes on sale for the same as employee price and sometime cost so please....quit your crying and thanks for shopping at best buy haha
Pyython1Mar 24th 2010 6:40PM
Then "HOW COME" you never came forward when "Best Buy" drove my favorite, "Circuit City", out of business? I loved CC & was extremely dissappointed when B.B. 'cornered the market' as far as electronics goes? They may have CC's in other cities but I'm stuck. Personally, I can't stand 'em & GO OUT OF MY WAY to another city to buy electronics. I can't stand 'em & their shoddy business practtices but that's the way the market crumbles!
mkscorpion3283Dec 13th 2009 5:24PM
The PS3 slim is obviously the version the article refers to. Older model PS3's (like the one I have) cannot bitstream hd audio sources.
Virginia12063Dec 16th 2009 10:00AM
MK, I have an older PS3, about 3 yrs old. Does this mean there is no WiFi feature?
limitedwarningDec 13th 2009 7:45PM
Cd's and dvd's are still in the dark ages..What we need is put all movies and cd's on a mb card. and build a mb machine that can play and burn mb card to mb card. I'm talking about the same mb card that a ps3 has. as small as that. and go even to a smaller mb size for your mp3 the size of a postage stamp to fit in your mp3 player. No more downloading music all you do is buy a postage stamp size mb card with the music already on it for your mp3 and your ready to go. It's time for newer technology and get rid of cd's and dvd's once and for all.
sigmastefDec 16th 2009 10:32AM
this guys right on the money about the ps3. but i also had an insignia in my bedroom and the damndest thing happened to it. my wife and i were watching a movie one night and our cat walked across the remote and the damn thing made a loud pop and never worked again. not the remote but the player itself. my little buddy must have somehow hit the self destruct code !
Thomas HoustonDec 16th 2009 2:14PM
Any luck getting a replacement?
stheel4Dec 16th 2009 10:43AM
The superior picture quality of Blu-ray is worth the cost with a decent 40" or larger display , and the superior audio is more than worth it over the outdated dvd audio codecs and online movies with the picture and current audio quality of Blu-ray are at least 10 years away if in fact we ever get both via online sources.
pd39Dec 16th 2009 12:16PM
Best Buy screwed me out of partial refund with their "restocking" fee. I returned a printer/scanner that wouldn't even turn on. They tried, their "geek squad experts" tried. Nothing. It was a manufacture screw up, and they said they wouldn't be putting it back on the shelf. There was no other model in my price range with the same features, so I wasn't going to buy another. They STILL insisted on company policy of charging a 15% restocking fee, and charged me $74.
I will NEVER shot Best Buy again!
k9spencer1Dec 16th 2009 1:49PM
We went to C.B. Joes and bought a 50" Plasma LG and got the LG 1000 - watt Blu-Ray with it. Love both of them. The LG Blu-Ray has everything, Netflix, Pics.,music,ect. just recently watched Journey to the center of the Earth in 3-D. That was great. It even has a dock for our I-Pod.
Good luck with what ever you get.
t bassDec 16th 2009 2:47PM
I am an installer and this guy is on point with the PS3 as a key component to any home theater. As far as Best Buy .......Utilize the internet and save money on the equipment and installation and save THOUSANDS.
NiceoneDec 16th 2009 5:14PM
I bought a blue ray player panasonic to go with our 50 inch panasonic plasma..Now some of the blue ray movies say that some players need to have an update from the blue ray manufacturor. I have called twice panasonic for it, and am still waiting..Without this player is just average as any other player..Totally disappointed
NickJan 3rd 2010 7:47AM
This article gave the worst possible advice imaginable. Stay FAR, FAR away from ANYTHING Insignia related, I once bought an Insignia HDTV that broke down a month after the 12 month warranty. I called a tv repairman and he said he couldn't in good conscience fix the tv and that I might as well buy a better brand tv.
Also, my PS3 very inconsistently plays Blu-Ray movies and even PS3 games. It skips, freezes, and gets disc read errors for no apparent reason. If that sounds like a good investment to you, by all means. At least you won't get bent over and drilled as hard as I did when I paid $600 originally for mine...
mikemaj82Mar 23rd 2010 4:59PM
I have an original 60GB from when it came out and it's been very good to me. you people must be abusing it, leaving it in an area where it gets too hot, or tossing it around. it is a solid piece with a less than 2% failure rate.
DawnMar 23rd 2010 5:34PM
We have a PS3 and a 50 inch Panasonic monitor. Blu-Ray DVD'slook great, but we wanted to avoid the hasle of dropping off the DVD at the rental store. We decided to take advantage of the free trial period from Netflix for streaming movies. However, after receiving the install CD, which we need to load EACH TIME we want to downoad a movie, we became very diappointed with the small selection of HD movies available on Netflix. The inventory is miniscule - there are 100 movies listed in each category (Action, Romance, Indy,etc) but many of the movies are listed in several categories. And there is not a large number of recently released movies. Down-loading was slow, and some movies that were listed as HD were not. We cancelled our service after 2 weeks. Until Netflix has a larger catalog, we'll go the old route and rent a Blu-Ray DVD.
jimbo chiliMar 23rd 2010 8:04PM
wish they'd start manufacturing HD DVR's - - not the DVR boxes the providers give you , but the ones that use your own discs and connect to cable and sattelite inputs - like the VCR's were like , but these will be HD and use discs -