Switched Asks: Do Personal E-Shoppers Get It Right?

After I signed up, Covet gave me a series of questions asking me to select which of two celebrities' styles I most liked: Rachel Bilson vs. Kelly Osbourne; Vanessa Hudgens vs., well, anyone not Vanessa Hudgens. After a while, Covet presented my style profile: Edgy Modern/Edgy Boho. While I despise the term "Boho," and would only classify a triangle as edgy, the examples they gave were actually pretty appropriate. I do like edgier clothing, but with a soft, cosmopolitan touch.
Next, Covet sent me through a list of silhouettes, and I had to choose patterns and styles I didn't like, which was difficult. Yes, I'm a fan of plaid, but only when it's subtle. Leopard print is acceptable, but not always. Here is the problem with matrix-based profiles: No room for exceptions. Without question, the part I liked best was getting to select prices. My mother always said a girl should never skimp on a great winter coat, but good luck getting me to spend three digits on a T-shirt. Covet did a great job of letting me customize how much I would want to drop and on what, ensuring that I wasn't getting bombarded by profiles of stuff I couldn't afford.
When my first stylized e-mail arrived, I was thrilled. The Internet had been scoured, my personality diluted into tiny bits, and -- I hoped -- my next "It" coat sent to my in-box. To my dismay, however, the majority of the stuff was horrible. Fortunately, Covet let me peruse and point out what I hated, and my next e-mail (The service lets you choose how frequently mail arrives.) was slightly better. The third e-mail I received was okay (still some suspicious Ed Hardy), but a couple of gems appeared. Covet's premise was correct: The more I let it know what I hated and loved, the better it got at predicting both.
My best buying still springs from me, a mouse, and my never-ending feeds and discount sites, but Covet does present an easy alternative (probably better for someone less picky). Still, even if it's manned by a group of geniuses, a predictive matrix can never fully replicate simple human taste.

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
ash said 5:12PM on 11-17-2009
wow...nice.. except no it wasn't.. Vanessa Hudgens is regularly on top ten style lists so whats your problem with her?? The way you worded that, made you sound as if you had a prejudice against HER not her style.. Have some respect
Reply
Leila Brillson said 5:24PM on 11-17-2009
Note: I come from a high-fashion background, so I have a particular taste.
I don't think Vanessa Hudgens has great style (though, she has been known to rock the Zac Posen once and again). I think she has a stylist's style, like the majority of the people on the "best dressed list" who actually pay people to dress them. Find me a celeb that doesn't have a stylist (Olsens, Chloe Sevigny, Tilda, Gwen, and while Rihanna does, she is very proactive in her image), and I'll show them style love. But I am but one writer, and the world of style is fickle, but Van Hud isn't going to be remembered as a vanguard for her work with, oh, say, Ecko Red.