Tumblr 101: Tips And Tricks To Get Started
Sebastian Thrun: Google's Driverless Car
Radiohead's Jonny Greenwood Doesn't Hate MP3s
We live in an age when the fidelity of our music is seemingly less important than our ability to easily access, transport, and share it. As vinyl records were eventually replaced almost entirely by CDs as the predominant music format, MP3s and other files have now become the standard. They are digitally compressed (to varying degrees), making them sound significantly 'thinner' (read: lower sampling rates) than their disc-based counterparts.
But composer and Radiohead member Jonny Greenwood sees things a bit differently. "They sound fine to me," he told the New Yorker when asked whether MP3 was a satisfactory medium for his music. "They can even put a helpful crunchiness onto some recordings. We listened to a lot of nineties hip-hop during our last album, all as MP3s, all via AirTunes. They sounded great, even with all that technology in the way. MP3s might not compare that well to a CD recording of, say, string quartets, but then, that's not really their point."
He says the desire for higher-quality formats primarily belongs to "thirty-something men who lurk in hi-fi shops, discussing signal purity and oxygen-free cables and FLACs" -- a group with which he associates himself, to some degree.
Greenwood goes on to compare MP3s' imperfections to analog tape's hiss. "I was happy using cassettes when I was fifteen, but I'm sure they were sneered at in their day by audiophiles," he said. "If I'm on a train, with headphones, MP3s are great. At home, I prefer CD or vinyl, partly because they sound a little better in a quiet room and partly because they're finite in length and separate things, unlike the endless days and days of music stored on my laptop."
Interesting thoughts from a man rather qualified to speak about such matters. [From: New Yorker, via Gizmodo]
16 Grammys Looks That Weren't Working
Whitney Houston Dead: Singer Dies at 48, Body Found in Beverly Hilton Hotel
Worst Movie Mistakes: Date Night Edition (PHOTOS)
Whitney Houston Autopsy: Cause of Death Determined?
Whitney Houston, Bobbi Kristina: Late Singer's Daughter Hospitalized
PHOTOS: President Obama's Kissing Technique
Whitney Houston Dead: Stars React to Legend's Sudden Death
Adele Five-Year Break? Singer Plans to Focus on Relationship, Write 'Happy Record'
How Hattie Lost 300 Pounds: 'I Was Ready To Do Whatever It Took To Survive'
Jennifer Hudson Whitney Tribute: Grammy President Reveals Why Singer Was Chosen for Musical Memorial
Grammy 2012 Winners' List: Adele Sweeps Music's Biggest Night
Matt Bomer Comes Out As Gay
3 Economic Misconceptions That Need to Die
5-Hour Energy: A Success Equal Parts Caffeine, Chemistry and Meditation
Grammy Awards 2012: The Best & Worst Of The Red Carpet!
People With Easy-To-Pronounce Names More Likely To Succeed, Study Says
Photos Of Dead Lacrosse Player's Injured Body Shown To Jury
12 Grammys Stars Who Gave Good Style
The Top 10 Slacker Colleges
15 Funny Valentine's Day Cards
Mystery Disease Kills Thousands
WATCH: 25 Million Tons Of Japan Tsunami Debris Headed Directly Our Way
Oprah Under Fire For Controversial Tweet
JUNGLE SURVIVAL: Marines Drink Snake Blood, Eat Insects
PHOTOS: Thank God For Grown-Up Glamour
Scuba-Diving Murder Trial: Prosecutors Drop One Charge Against Husband
PHOTOS: Kate Spends Valentine's Day Solo!
Remembering The People's Ballerina
Taylor Swift Does Great Depression Chic
PHOTO: Kate Upton Scores 'Sports Illustrated' Swimsuit Issue Cover!
PHOTOS: Beautiful Scars
15 Funny Valentine's Day Quotes
Comments
3
Subscribe to commentstaintSep 4th 2009 4:14PM
depends on how they're encoded.
under 256k = awful
256k and up = decent
320k = hard to tell it's an mp3
RyanSep 4th 2009 10:31PM
Mp3s don't use a lower sampling rate (all standard encodings use 44.1KHz, just like a CD). The compression comes from leaving out some data, which the encoding algorithm predicts you wouldn't hear anyway. Basically, if there's a whole range of frequencies of sound blaring at different levels (which is what happens with music) some of them will be masked by others, and there's a decent model of how people hear sound that can predict which parts of the signal won't be heard by a human ear.
I guess my point is that yeah, mp3s compress data, but they don't do it by reducing the sampling rate.
DerpSep 5th 2009 1:19AM
MP3's do sound fine, until you hear them compared to the full sized versions. The musical content may be there, but the full low and high frequency sound of the real thing gives you music you can experience rather than just listen to.
If you just want to hear the melody and rhythm of a song, then MP3 is fine. If you want the musical experience that the artist, producers and engineers wanted you to hear, then MP3's don't cut it.