
Audio/Video, Computers, Advice, Editor's Picks, Windows Software, Reviews, Home Audio
Switched Download: Hulu Desktop Eases Up PC TV-Watching Experience

What it is: Hulu Desktop is a free, Flash-based application for Mac and Windows that plays video from the Hulu Web site, including full episodes and clips from ABC, Fox, and NBC television shows, plus a smattering of movies.
What we like about it: Hulu desktop brings a high level of polish to what was already a fantastic video site. Once you get the hang of the left-to-right organization, the interface is very easy and intuitive to navigate. You start by searching for a series, selecting from the most popular videos, or hitting up a cue of programs you've already built in this app or on Hulu's Web site. Then you click to the right to select an individual episode to watch.
The process if far more straightforward than scrolling around the Hulu.com site. And you don't even need to use the mouse. You can also navigate by simple keyboard shortcuts (directional arrows to move around menus, the space bar to pause, etc); or you can wield remote controls for the Apple Front Row or Windows Media Center applications. There are plenty of options during playback, such as fast-forwarding or rewinding the video by sliding along a timeline that pops up at the bottom of the screen. And multitaskers can reduce the currently playing video to a preview window while searching for new videos to play or add to the cue.
Image quality is identical to the high (by Web-video standards) level provided on Hulu's Web site. The 480p feed is close to what you'd get from a standard-definition DVD. And streaming was very smooth, even given the inconsistent bandwidth from our janky Time-Warner cable Internet service.
What we don't like: The app is demanding, requiring at least a 1.8-gigahertz Core Duo processor and two gigabytes of RAM. Older PCs, and certainly netbooks, will be hard pressed. (For laughs, we tried a Windows XP laptop with a 1.73-gigahertz Pentium M chip and 512 megabytes of RAM, and then watched stop-motion video.) Even on a powerful computer (a late-model MacBook Pro) the app often froze or crashed when we tried multitasking, such as watching one video while browsing a list of others. (In all fairness, it is still beta software.)
In streamlining the interface, Hulu stripped out community and networking features, such as access to reviews and discussions, as well as tools for editing clips that you can send to friends or embed in a Web page. All are still available on the Hulu site, however.
As always with Hulu, the video selection is frustratingly (and purposely) incomplete. A few recent episodes of current shows are available-typically the last five. If you want to watch, say, the (so far) five-season House series from scratch, you'll have to pick up the DVDs or buy episodes from Amazon or iTunes. (For the extra money, the latter two also provide better-looking HD versions.) Of course you have to watch occasional commercials with Hulu, but far fewer than on old-school TV. And hey, the videos are free, after all.
The most frustrating aspect of Hulu Desktop is how damn nice it is. Given the slick interface and compatibility with remote controls, this app seems perfect for a TV. But Hulu says it has no intentions of making the program available for set-top boxes such as Apple TV, Xbox 360, or network-connected Blu-ray players. We can hope for a hack, though. (Andrew Pile has been trying to get the app running on Apple TV, but so far it's providing only stuttering frame rates and frequent crashes.) Of course you can plug your computer into the big screen. But given Hulu's heavy resource requirements, this may not be an option for repurposing an old system as a media PC.
Bottom Line: Hulu Desktop provides even easier access than the Web site to an already-great video collection. The slick interface brings Internet video a giant step closer to the quality of an old-school TV (or TiVo) experience. Best of all, it's free.
Download the Hulu Desktop here.



Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
jeremy said 4:57PM on 6-02-2009
"even given the inconsistent bandwidth from our janky Time-Warner cable Internet service"
isn't switched owned by aol/time-warner????
Reply
bob said 8:59AM on 6-28-2009
Will COMCAST block people from watching "TV" on the internet for free , if they dont subscribe to or drop their cable tv service ?
Reply