Audio/Video, Columns, TV, CES 2008
HD-DVD's Long Walk Back to the Locker Room of Shame
It would be a mistake to say that HD-DVD will cease to exist tomorrow. In fact, expect to see just the opposite of that. HD-DVD continue on as an underground favorite format, much like Betamax did in the 70s and laser discs did in the 90s. Remember laser discs, the giant optical discs that came before DVD, the stuff of early home theater buffs who could tell you a thing or two about digital mastering way before half of Hollywood was even Bar Mitzvah'd? No? How about beta, the superior tape format that Sony wanted you to buy instead of VHS?
I originally thought HD-DVD was completely done for before the Consumer Electronics Show. Warner's Blu-Ray-exclusive announcement and the HD-DVD group's decision to back out of their keynote made it sound like they would go away with a whimper. On the final day of the conference, however, I took one last walk by the HD-DVD booth just to see what was up. After all, I'm a sucker for a good heartbreak story.
"So I looked on bestbuy.com this morning," began the booth attendant, speaking to three half-asleep attendees who, by my estimation, were there more for the chair rest than the presentation. "You can now buy an HD-DVD drive for $179. That also comes with ten free discs. Ten free discs! That easily makes HD-DVD the best deal in high definition."
The guy had a point. Think about it -- for $179, you can get a high-end HD-DVD player that will also upscale your regular DVDs to high-definition resolution. It will also play your Super-Audio CDs. You also get ten free HD-DVD discs. Go try to buy ten new regular-definition DVDs for $179 -- I dare you. That evening I was ordering an HD-DVD drive from bestbuy.com. Call me a vulture if you will, but I'll be enjoying this winter in high-def heaven. Heck - I might even cancel my Netflix account for a few months and save another $50 or so.
That closing value on the HD-DVD format really is hard to beat. Even if another HD-DVD title never comes out, the closing cost of the format -- along with its hardware -- is easily worth the cost to anyone with a high-definition television. Is it an investment for the far future? Not so much, but most of us who already have home theaters and high-definition televisions aren't exactly known for our electronics long-term investment acumen -- we'll all have new TVs, receivers, and speakers in a few years anyway.
Anyway, with Apple's new iTunes Movie Rentals and NetFlix opening up the "View It Now" service to unlimited views, disc-based movies' days are numbered.
Enjoy the fire sale. I know I will.
Related Links:



Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Jonathan said 2:22PM on 2-15-2008
I think that apple is on the right track with the apple tv! I think that HD without having the disc is coming faster than you think. Plus I hate it when dvds or other formated discs come up missing. With apple tv i will not have to worry about that! Its coming i tell ya!
Reply
johnson said 2:00PM on 1-16-2008
"Anyway, with Apple's new iTunes Movie Rentals and NetFlix opening up the "View It Now" service to unlimited views, disc-based movies' days are numbered."
Have you sir actually had the pleasure of downloading a high definition movie over the net? try it! you will change the last portion of this article. I promise! dvd is not going anywhere anytime soon either, heck- most people dont even have high speed internet, and the few that do are so disgusted about the download time, that they too would rather have the actual disc, not to mention that once you buy the movie, you dont have to pay another 3-4 bucks just to watch it again! for 24.99 i`d much rather have the disc to see as many times as i would like! apple and microsoft will fail!
Reply
Joshua Fruhlinger said 2:05PM on 1-16-2008
Johnson:
I completely agree with you, at least in the near-term. I love watching BD's in 1080P with lossless 7.1 sound, and I know that won't be happening tomorrow with downloads. I remember when HD downloads first appeared on Xbox live, it took me 3 days to download Clash of The Titans - and that was only in 720P!
So, yes, you are absolutely right that download HD is a bear. Will that always be the case, though? I don't think so. By the time HD televisions become as ubiquitous as the standard-definition DVD player, I think bandwidth and streaming technologies will have caught up enough to make on-demand HD a reality. You better bet Apple and Netflix are thinking the same thing.
Reply
Chris Calwell said 11:54AM on 1-17-2008
I've never seen an HD-DVD or Blu-Ray player that claims to be able to play Super Audio CD or DVD-Audio discs. Are you sure about the claim that HD-DVD players can decode them?
Reply
John said 12:33AM on 1-17-2008
Joshua, I can't find the 'HD-DVD drive for $179 that comes with ten free discs' deal anywhere online, and I scoured buy.com. Got a link?
Reply
Joshua Fruhlinger said 8:42AM on 1-17-2008
John: At Amazon, at least at the time of CES, you get 2 free in the box, pick three from a list, and then send in for another 5.
Reply
Cliff said 1:43PM on 1-17-2008
PS3 can play super audio CDs. I believe blu ray players can play sacd (both sony inventions I believe). I guess its possible hd dvd can too.
Reply
D said 1:48PM on 1-17-2008
Blue-ray hand-down wins. If you acutally take both formates and compare them you will see. Also up-scaling won't do much. It can't add detail, it can only make is brighter and the colors more vivid. I would not waste your money on HD-DVD, yes you do get more for the money but are you really getting more for the money? Think about it before just going out and buying.
Reply
Daniel Gaunt said 8:24AM on 1-18-2008
it's the PS3 that won it!
and HD-dvd drives are bount yo drop in price now, but if there are no films to watch on them it'll be a complete waste of money even if it is only 100
Reply