Best Buy Caught Faking Low Nintendo Wii Supplies
Nintendo's Wii console has been very hard to find for a long time now -- so long that some are calling shenanigans. A lot of folks think that Nintendo is artificially creating news and demand by keeping supplies of its little white console low. Those claims have never been substantiated, but now we have some proof that some other players are getting in on the game. The Consumerist has is reporting that Best Buy employees are clearing out their Wii inventories by broadcasting that they're down to a single Wii console -- over and over again.
The report was filed by a witness at the Princeton, New Jersey Best Buy. The witness saw an employee parade around holding a Wii over her head while another employee announced "Julie is now walking through the store with our last Nintendo Wii! If you're looking for a Nintendo Wii, please look for Julie!" Someone in the store grabbed the box and bought the console, of course. 30 minutes later, another employee did the same thing, with another Wii held aloft for all to see. The witness claims he overheard the store's managers discussing the scheme and planning to send Julie out a third time forty minutes later.
This isn't the first time Best Buy has been caught doing something shady: Earlier this year, some branches of the chain set up a second, secret version of the Best Buy Web site, which was accessible only from within the store and had higher prices than the public Web site, presumable to keep people from getting lower in-store prices. The discount chain has also been accused of tricking people into signing up for subscriptions to MSN, as well as selling a hard drive that contained only bathroom tiles.
From The Consumerist
Related Links:
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 7)
steve said 2:36AM on 2-14-2008
Yeah I hear you bret. I also work at Best Buy. People spice up their boring lives and make themselves feel better if they can put a conspiracy behind something. You are right, the truth is that if they bothered to look it up they would see that Nintendo is a very small company compared to Microsoft and Sony. Yet they have sold more units than each. The fact is that they just can't keep up with demand nor can their suppliers. They want to talk about ad product that can't be put out on the floor yet. Well the fact is if we hold something off the floor for the ad is because we are legally bound to have a certain amount in the store for Sunday. If not we could be sued. What is ever worse is they think we get them in regularly. They are shipped directly from Nintendo N.A. and at my store we have had 4 shipments since before Christmas. Those 4 totalled less than 100 units. As for the store that concocted the sales plan, I do consider that to be unethical and should be addressed by their district managers.
Reply
Iris said 4:50PM on 11-13-2007
As long as people create the deman we will keep getting scammed with shortages and unethical techniques to get us to buy. I bet if everyone stopped buying the Wii or any other high demand product the will miraculously increase the supple and then have to lower the prices!!!!
Reply
Samantha said 11:17AM on 11-13-2007
And Why is this store still in business? Tactics like these should be illegal and probably are.
Reply
Margot said 1:44AM on 7-10-2008
That's ridiculous. How can you label all stores as shady just because of what a few have done? I work at Best Buy and I haven't heard about ANY of this until now. That site isn't used to trick customers, or at least my store doesn't use it like that. There are two sites. One is In-Store, which shows what the prices are in our particular store and the other is National, which shows the prices that customers see. We are taught to use the In-Store site as a product reference. Not for price, but for actually looking up information about the product (like how much RAM it has or what kind of cords it needs) because some people don't know that off the top of their heads. If we are looking up prices, we look at the National site. You're supposed to look up that stuff everyday and change your price tags. I guess some people just aren't doing their jobs.
As for the Wii thing, that's just stupid, and I'm pissed that some stores are just that horrible. I've had my share of horrible Best Buy experiences, but NOTHING like that. It actually makes me ashamed for them.
Tom said 11:17AM on 11-13-2007
That doesn't surprise me at all. A few years ago, I was in a Best Buy, and had forgotten my credit card. A manager told me that wasn't a problem, then proceded to tell me how, and where to get a fake card. He said that as long as it 'swiped' they didn't care if it was real or not, they would get paid from the credit card company, and that was all they cared about.
Reply
Mike said 12:14PM on 11-13-2007
I bought a big flat screen T.V. and a nice surround sound system about 6-8 weeks ago and as I was paying, their computer conveniently shut down as the credit card was going through. I had to pay twice for the T.V. and I'm still dealing with my credit card company trying to get the other $1450.00 credited to my account!
I'm done with Best Buy! Circuit City has never given me a problem!
Reply
Emmy said 11:54AM on 11-13-2007
I work in a video game store, and I can say that although there aren't as many Wiis on the market as there are, say, XBox 360s, the "shortage" isn't nearly as bad as some stores would have you believe. Nintendo themselves aren't trying to cover up their Wii sales, it's mostly unscrupulous managers who devise these plans in order to sell every Wii they have as quickly as they can due to the public misconception that Wiis are nearly always "out of stock." I would be willing to bet that Wal-Mart and many other stores keep their "out of stock" Wiis in the warehouse, easily accessable by all employees, but unavailable to the public in order to continue generating the hype.
Reply
Chiabone said 12:20PM on 11-13-2007
I have a damn hard time believing that almost a full YEAR after launch that Nintendo is still not producing enough Wii's to meet the demand. Even Sony and Microsoft didn't take that long to get PS3 and 360 (respectively) in stock after initial shortages. Even with the Playstation 2, Sony was able to ramp up production and get the consoles out within 6 months, and they deal in other things besides Videogames. Nintendo is just trying to keep the hype up for their inferior system. I have no desire to get one, but I am tired of people coming into the Gamestop that I work at and asking if we have any Wii's in stock. We really don't, but that is only because Nintendo is not shipping them. There is no way any person with common sense thinks that they cannot get the untils out to the masses.
Reply
nancy said 1:42PM on 11-13-2007
I was told to just ask at any of the stores: Walmart, Toys R Us, Target, and Game Stop. They usually get shipments through the week. Most of the stock is kept in the back until people ASK for them. In fact, I was talking to guy in Walmart this past week. He said they would be getting more in but were currently out. He said they had shipments come in everyday.
Reply
funkysmellin_monkey said 1:00PM on 11-13-2007
Does everything always have to be a conspiracy? Give it a rest already! OMG!! My husband works at gamestop. There really is a shortage and you want to know why? Because people love the Wii and they keep buying it!!
They got three in stock one day and I went to go get one and the three got sold out in 24 hours. That's why there's a shortage. Because every other day they get more and in hours people come in and buy them. With christmas coming, it'll be impossible to find one. That's all there is to it.
It's not a conspiracy. Think about it. If Nintendo could sell a thousand in one day, why would they opt to sell a hundred in one day just to scare people into thinking they didn't have enough? Does that make any sense? What kind of business sceme is that?
Reply
Joe said 12:37PM on 11-13-2007
Its articles like this that should not even be written tarnish business reputation just to get readers. First of all when Best Buy does get a good amount of Wii's they do put them out when they do not they pull off tricks like Julies' store so the same customer will not buy more then one given other customers chance to buy one.They do it to keep the customer in the store if they do not get a Wii chances are they will get another system, this is not a dirty trick just business. To Samantha up there this business is still in business because they know how to run a business sorry to tell you every business does this kind of things not only BestBuy we dont live in a fantasy world where life is squeaky clean.
Reply
kan said 12:44PM on 11-13-2007
No surprise when it comes to Best Buy scamming. In St. Petersburf, Fl. they pulled the old "bait & switch" on me. I went in for the advertised special (too good to be true) on a computer. When they, of course, didn't have any left, the new salesman complained, "I don't know why they always advertise specials and then don't let us bring out more than just one..." I'll never go back. Too bad they loose so many repeat customers. Now that's just bad business.
Reply
Randy said 1:09PM on 11-13-2007
It's not just Best Buy, I know for a fact, the Target in Wyoming, MI told customers for at least 1 week that they were out of stock, when in fact they had about 60 in the back room, being saved for the sunday flyer.
I believe that games are being played in a lot of stores. But If I ask for one and I'm being told they are out when in fact they are not, That is wrong!
Reply
allyfallydillydally said 12:53PM on 11-13-2007
funkysmellin_monkey,
Wake up and smell the conspiracy. Why does gamestop only get three units in at a time? Because Nintendo controls the shortage frenzy. If Nintendo actually sent out enough units to satisfy the masses, then people would lose interest in the Wii. By keeping the hype going, they feed the public's need for "gotta have it" and thus keeps Nintendo in the minds of the weak. Also, Nintendo still airs commercials for a product they don't have enough stock of. Why is that? Again, the meek are drawn to the hype.
If you are smart, you would boycott Nintendo for its deceptive practices and support Sony or Microsoft.
Reply
sara said 12:59PM on 11-13-2007
The shortage must be fake. It doesn't exist in my neck of the woods, that is for sure! My son wanted a Wii, and we promised it to him if he brought home all A's. He did, and that night went out and picked one up. Target had them, Walmart had them, Gamestop (EB) had them. All stores had 3-4 in stock, if memory serves. We didn't have to get in line at 4 am, we just walked in Walmart and bought one. All these stores still have the Wii in stock every time I go into the store. I always look to see, because I keep hearing about this "shortage", and I like to chuckle about it each time I see the big white Wii boxes on the shelf. If you need a Wii, come to St. Augustine, FL. No shortage here.
Reply
Neuticles said 12:58PM on 11-13-2007
Try having your credit get smeared when they finance you. Best Buy sucks x2.
Reply
sara said 1:08PM on 11-13-2007
funkysmellin_monkey:
Your husband works at a Gamestop, yet you were unable to get a Wii? Couldn't he just pick one up while at work?
Oh, and also-this article is about Best Buy faking their supplies-not Nintendo.
Please, learn to read-and spell, before commenting further.
Reply
iser18 said 5:05PM on 11-13-2007
if it's sold at the same price why wouldn't they want to sell as many as possible
Reply
Joyce said 1:22PM on 11-13-2007
I called the best buy store looking for a Wii and was told that they had some coming in on Sunday and the people line up 2 hours b4 th store opened... I than called Target and they had some coming too the same day and they were getting 38 and they normally have 5 people waiting on them... so guess where we went to get the WII system Target...
I will not buy another thing from Best buy.. when my charge is paid off I will cancel the card and will never apply for a new one...
Reply
L said 1:26PM on 11-13-2007
I bought my daughter a hand-held game at a Kmart 2 weeks ago and the gentleman who sold it to me informed me that they had alot of the Wii's in the back room and were not allowed to sell them until Black Friday and that he knew for a fact that the local Target was doing the same thing.
Reply