Audio/Video, Computers, Editor's Picks, Reviews
Hands-On Review: The Return of Winamp
For me, it was the sound of a llama being flogged. That was my baptism into the world of digital music -- a world that, for a brief moment in time there in the '90s, was like one of those Toys 'R' Us shopping sprees they used to advertise on TV where some lucky kid got to run up and down the aisles filling up his shopping basket with freebies. It's hard to believe it's been 10 years since I first installed Winamp on my dorm room computer, pressed play and was introduced to the MP3 by Winamp's mysterious, "It really whips the llama's ass" jingle.
Though Winamp has since faded into a fond memory for many of us as a result of our iPod dependencies, the player is hoping to reclaim some its former glory. Today, on anniversary number 10 on 10/10, Winamp is launching a new player that's been completely re-built from the ground up. Is Winamp 5.5 enough to coax an iTunes-addicted public back into the llama's arms? Let's take a tour.
First, a little disclosure: 1) AOL is the corporate papa to both Winamp and Switched.com. This didn't affect my review no matter how many times I was bullied by my bosses. 2) Though I used a PC to test Winamp, I'm a Mac user and an iTunes user. I'm no iTunes zealot; I just find it convenient since it's already on my computer and works seamlessly with my iPod.
First Impressions
The most immediate change in 5.5 is that Winamp is now one big window with different, configurable panels within (see the gallery below for a look-see). Gone are the separate windows for the player, the playlist, the visualizer and any of the other plug-ins you could download. Some people found the separate windows annoying, but I kind of liked them. Then again, as I start to organize my music and personal settings in 5.5, it's obvious that one window is the way to go. As for the rest of the appearance, Winamp is still completely skinnable and it now displays album art.
Playlists
Besides a shamefully underutilized exercise mix, I'm not much of a playlist person. But for those who are, you can create playlists in Winamp with as little or as much criteria as you want. Are you in the mood for country songs from the '80s that are all under 3:00 minutes long? Winamp will scour your library for them. If you happen to be handy with database query languages, you can actually use those to formulate your own super-nerdy, super-custom lists.
Discovery
For discovering new music, there's easy access to Winamp's user-generated Shoutcast Radio network -- though this really isn't any more helpful or entertaining than the Internet radio I can already get through iTunes. What is helpful and entertaining, however, is the free XM Satellite Radio I can listen to through Winamp thanks to a cozy relationship between XM and AOL. Additionally, there's a Web browser built into Winamp. Use it to browse your favorite MP3 blogs, and any links to music files are automatically cataloged in a list for convenient listening or downloading.
Portability
All of this is great for playing music on a PC (and not a Mac), but it's Winamp's new proficiencies in taking music off of the computer that might tempt the iTunes faithful. First, it's definitely worth noting that the player is now compatible with the iPod and every other digital media player out there. Of course, that excludes your copy-protected tracks purchased from the iTunes Store.
The big addition to Winamp 5.5 is Winamp Remote. Through this Web interface you can access your home music library no matter where you are. All that's required is a Web browser, which means Remote works with Macs as well as with the PS3, Xbox 360 and Nintendo Wii. Best of all, it works on Web-enabled phones too -- and it works quite well.
Verdict
So, is Winamp a viable alternative to iTunes? In the end it'll come down to preference. For some people, the differences between Winamp and iTunes won't be compelling enough to make the switch. For me, Winamp Remote would definitely seal the deal if I were a regular PC user. Hearing that llama being punished over my cell phone's tinny speaker for the first time was like Quantum Leaping right back to my college dorm room ... minus my roommate's questionable collection of black light posters.
Get Winamp here.
Gallery: Winamp 5.5
Related Links:




Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
GilmourD said 2:49PM on 10-10-2007
Isn't in a conflict of interest for AOL News to review a product owned by AOL?
Reply
TheDrake said 3:27PM on 10-10-2007
Tom, good stuff & interesting read- I like that everything old is new again, now we'll see if it sticks. Ugh GilmourD... was that a rhetorical question or do you expect an answer? 1/2 of the 3rd paragraph is devoted to disclosing this relationship. So, let's say, an NBC film critic can't review a Universal film? Odd criticism of the story I thought. Don't be a clown, kid.
Reply
hinterleitner said 4:14PM on 10-10-2007
> I'm a Mac user ...
> Winamp Remote works _with Macs as well_ as ...
> For me, Winamp Remote would definitely seal the deal if I were a regular PC user.
is not there a contradiction?
Reply
Atomic Vampire said 4:29PM on 10-10-2007
I have used nothing but Winamp for years. Love it!
Reply
sexkitten1sex said 4:53PM on 10-10-2007
I want to hear a review not anyone work for or site owned by Aol/TimeWarner
Reply
Acid Reign said 5:57PM on 10-10-2007
    Does this new Winamp display captions/lyrics while the tune is playing? Without user intervention and an ugly little mismatched window that doesn't match the skin? That's where Windows Media Player since about version 7 on, kills all the other players!
Reply
Mark said 6:55PM on 10-10-2007
GilmourD says:
Isn't in a conflict of interest for AOL News to review a product owned by AOL?
10/10/07 2:49 PM
Yes....aaand? Who's going to do anything about it?
Reply